Most business owners can answer this question almost immediately: Who is the employee you really cannot afford to lose?
Maybe it is the salesperson who has spent 15 years building relationships with your largest customers. Maybe it is the operations person who somehow knows how everything actually works, including all the things nobody ever bothered to write down. Or maybe it is the employee who can step in when you are gone, calm down an unhappy customer, solve a production problem and answer questions that everyone else brings directly to you.
Now imagine that person walking into your office on a Tuesday morning and saying, “I need to talk to you.”
There is probably at least one employee whose resignation would cause an immediate, visceral reaction. I suspect the technical business term is something along the lines of, Oh shit.
Owners spend a lot of time thinking about the risks they can see. They insure buildings and equipment. They monitor cash flow. They worry about competitors, recessions, taxes, lawsuits and losing a major customer. But there is another form of concentration risk that gets considerably less attention: What percentage of the value of your company is walking around every day in the heads of two or three people?
That may be a much bigger number than you think.
What Is Key-Employee Risk?
When people talk about concentration risk in a business, they usually think about customers. If one customer represents 35% of your revenue, everyone immediately understands the problem. Lose that customer and the business could be in trouble.
Key-employee concentration is similar, except it is harder to see on an income statement. Suppose you have an employee who manages your five largest customer relationships, another who oversees most of your operations, and a third who has become the person employees turn to whenever you are not around. Your revenue may look diversified, but the people responsible for producing and protecting that revenue may not be diversified at all.
That creates several different risks. The obvious one is resignation, particularly if a competitor recruits the employee. But people also become disabled, retire, die, move across the country or simply decide they want to do something different with their lives. None of those possibilities requires anyone to do anything wrong.
The problem is that a successful company can gradually become dependent on particular people without the owner ever consciously deciding to make it that way.
How Do I Know If My Business Depends Too Much on One Employee?
A useful exercise is to forget everyone’s job title for a minute and think about what would actually happen if each employee disappeared tomorrow.
For each of your most important people, ask yourself:
- What revenue would realistically be at risk?
- Which customers have a stronger relationship with this person than with the company?
- What processes does this employee understand that nobody else fully understands?
- Who could perform the job tomorrow if necessary?
- How long would it take to find and train a replacement?
- Does this employee control important vendor, banking or other outside relationships?
- What decisions would immediately come back to me?
- Would the company still function normally if this person were unavailable for six months?
That last question is particularly useful because it changes the way owners tend to think about employees. Someone can be extraordinarily valuable without being a major concentration risk. If three other people understand the job and could absorb the responsibilities, losing the employee would hurt, but the business would continue operating.
The bigger problem is the employee for whom there is no obvious backup.
I see this as a people concentration test. The issue is not simply, “Who are my best employees?” It is, “Where have I accidentally created a single point of failure?”
Why Does This Matter If I’m Not Planning to Sell My Business?
Because this is not just an exit-planning problem.
If a critical employee leaves at 42 while you are 48 and planning to run the company for another 15 years, you still have a problem. You may suddenly find yourself handling work you thought you had delegated years ago. Growth plans may have to be postponed while you recruit. Customers may become nervous. Other employees may start wondering whether they should leave too.
But the issue becomes particularly important as you approach a sale or retirement because key-employee risk can become business-value risk. A buyer is not simply purchasing last year’s earnings. The buyer wants some confidence that those earnings will continue after the transaction.
Imagine two companies producing exactly the same profit. In one, customer relationships are spread across the organization, important processes are documented, management is deep and no single employee is indispensable. In the other, two people hold most of the customer relationships and institutional knowledge.
Those may look like identical companies on a spreadsheet. They are not identical businesses.
A prospective buyer is likely to care about whether the company’s important employees will remain after the owner leaves. The more dependent the company is on a few individuals, the more uncertainty there is around the durability of its future cash flow. That can affect how a buyer thinks about risk, deal terms and ultimately value.
For owners here in Indiana who expect the sale of their business to fund a meaningful portion of retirement, that connection is especially important. You aren’t just trying to retain good employees. You are trying to make the business itself more transferable.
Should I Pay a Key Employee More So They Won’t Leave?
Sometimes. But simply increasing someone’s salary isn’t necessarily the same thing as creating a retention strategy.
If a key employee is materially underpaid relative to the market, fixing compensation is an obvious place to start. At the same time, throwing another $20,000 into someone’s salary may not accomplish much if a competitor can simply offer $25,000 more next year.
The better question is:
What would make staying with this company increasingly valuable over time?
That can lead to several possibilities, depending on the employee and the business:
- A retention bonus tied to remaining with the company through a particular date or transition.
- A deferred-compensation arrangement in which meaningful benefits accumulate over several years.
- Performance bonuses tied to company or individual results.
- Phantom equity or another arrangement designed to give an employee some participation in the company’s growth without necessarily giving away actual ownership.
- An ownership opportunity for an employee who could eventually become part of the succession plan.
These arrangements can become complicated quickly. Tax treatment, ERISA considerations, securities issues, employment law and the specific design of the agreement all matter. This is an area where the owner’s attorney, CPA and financial advisor should be working from the same plan rather than independently designing pieces that don’t fit together.
There is also a more basic point that sometimes gets lost when people start designing compensation plans. Not every retention problem is a money problem. An employee who sees no path forward, hates working for the owner or has been doing the jobs of three people for five years may not be saved by a clever deferred-compensation arrangement.
What Is Phantom Equity?
Phantom equity is an interesting tool because it can address a problem many owners face: I want this person to benefit from the growth of the company, but I don’t necessarily want to make them an owner.
Despite the name, phantom equity generally doesn’t involve giving the employee actual shares of the company. Instead, the employee receives a contractual benefit whose value can be tied to the value or appreciation of the business, subject to the terms of the arrangement.
Suppose, for example, you have a senior employee who has been instrumental in growing the company. You would like that person to think more like an owner and participate financially if the company becomes significantly more valuable. At the same time, you may not want to deal with voting rights, minority ownership, distributions or having an actual shareholder whom you eventually need to buy out.
A properly structured phantom-equity arrangement may provide some of the economics of ownership without transferring actual ownership.
That does not make phantom equity automatically better than real equity. For the right successor, actual ownership may be exactly what you want. The point is that owners have more choices than the binary decision of “give them stock” or “give them nothing.”
What About Key-Person Life and Disability Insurance?
Retention planning addresses the risk that somebody chooses to leave. It doesn’t solve the problem if the person cannot continue working.
That is where key-person insurance can enter the discussion. With key-person life insurance, the business generally owns a policy on an important employee and is the beneficiary. If that employee dies, the proceeds can provide liquidity while the company deals with the financial consequences.
The same basic idea can apply to disability. Depending on the circumstances and coverage available, insurance can help provide resources if an important employee becomes unable to work.
But insurance is easy to misunderstand here. A check from an insurance company does not replace 20 years of institutional knowledge or magically preserve a customer’s relationship with a salesperson who is no longer there. Insurance provides money to deal with the problem. It does not eliminate the underlying concentration risk.
That distinction matters.
How Do I Make My Business Less Dependent on Key Employees?
The long-term objective shouldn’t be to make good employees less important. If you have exceptional people, you want them to be important.
The objective is to make the business less fragile.
I would think about that in four areas:
Retention. Are your most important people being compensated appropriately, and do they have a meaningful reason to stay for the next five or ten years?
Redundancy. Is there at least one other person who understands every critical function of the company? Cross-training is not exciting, but neither is discovering that only one employee knows how to run a process responsible for 30% of your revenue.
Relationships. Do major customers, vendors and outside partners have relationships with multiple people at the company? You want customers loyal to the organization, not exclusively to one employee.
Documentation. How much critical knowledge exists only inside someone’s head? Processes, passwords, contacts, pricing practices, customer history and operating procedures should increasingly belong to the business rather than to an individual.
This is not something you fix in a month. In fact, trying to eliminate key-person dependence overnight could create more problems than it solves. The goal is to gradually turn individual knowledge, relationships and capabilities into organizational assets.
What Does This Have to Do With Succession Planning?
Potentially, almost everything.
One of those employees you are terrified of losing may also be the person best positioned to eventually run or buy the company. If that is the case, retention planning and succession planning should not be treated as separate exercises.
Suppose you are 55 and hope to step away at 65. Your operations manager is 42, knows the company extremely well and has the trust of employees and customers. You could spend the next decade hoping that person stays. Or you could begin having a much more serious conversation about what staying might eventually lead to.
That does not mean promising the company to someone after one good year. It means thinking deliberately about career path, management responsibility, compensation, leadership development and possibly future ownership.
The irony is that the employee who creates your greatest concentration risk today may eventually become the person who makes the business transferable without you.
A Simple Key-Employee Stress Test
If you own a business, I would actually put names on paper and run through this exercise. Pick the two or three people whose departure would hurt the most and answer five questions for each:
- What breaks if this person disappears tomorrow?
- How much revenue or how many important relationships could be affected?
- Who is the backup?
- What financial reason does this person have to stay?
- What would the business look like six months after losing them?
You don’t need a complicated scoring system. The point is to expose dependencies that are easy to ignore while everything is going well.
If you get to question three and realize the answer is, “Well, I guess I would have to take over,” pay attention to that. If you are trying to build a company that eventually operates without you, discovering that every critical personnel problem ultimately lands back on your desk tells you something important.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a key employee?
There is no single definition that works for every company. In practical terms, I would define a key employee as someone whose prolonged absence or departure could materially affect revenue, operations, customer relationships, leadership or the value of the business.
Does key-person insurance keep an employee from leaving?
No. Key-person insurance addresses certain financial consequences associated with death and, depending on the coverage, disability. Retention incentives such as bonuses, deferred compensation or equity-related arrangements address a different problem: giving an employee reasons to remain with the company.
Should I give a key employee ownership in my company?
Maybe, but ownership is a much bigger decision than a retention bonus. Before giving away equity, an owner should think through voting rights, distributions, valuation, buy-sell provisions, what happens if the employee leaves and how the shares would eventually be repurchased. Alternatives such as phantom equity may be worth evaluating before transferring actual ownership.
Can losing a key employee reduce the value of my business?
It can. Buyers generally care about whether the company’s earnings, customer relationships and operations can continue after a transaction. Heavy dependence on a few employees can create uncertainty about how transferable those earnings really are.
The Bigger Question
Most owners understand that having 40% of revenue tied to one customer is dangerous. Far fewer stop to ask whether 40% of the company’s important relationships, knowledge or operational capability is tied to one employee.
Yet economically, the risks aren’t all that different.
The good news is that key-employee concentration is something you can work on long before you sell the company. You can build redundancy. You can document processes. You can broaden customer relationships. You can create thoughtful retention incentives. And, in some cases, you can turn a critical employee into a future leader or owner.
If your first reaction to imagining a particular employee leaving is Oh shit, I wouldn’t ignore that reaction. It is probably telling you something useful about your business.
For many owners, the real question isn’t simply whether the company can survive without you. It is whether it can survive without the other people who have quietly become indispensable too.