If you own a profitable small business, you’re probably familiar with the balancing act of keeping employees happy while managing expenses and making sure there’s enough money left over to support the business. Good employees aren’t cheap, and replacing them can be even more expensive. Meanwhile, you’re paying what may feel like an enormous amount in taxes, particularly if your business is doing well.
One option that many small business owners overlook is establishing a retirement plan. I suspect part of the reason is that 401(k) plans have a reputation for being expensive and complicated, particularly for businesses with only a handful of employees. And frankly, that reputation isn’t entirely undeserved. But changes to federal tax law have made the economics considerably more attractive for certain small businesses.
In fact, depending on the circumstances, a business owner could provide $15,000 in retirement benefits to employees at an after-tax contribution cost of approximately $3,400. And that’s before considering the potential benefits of improved employee retention or the owner’s own retirement savings.
Keeping Good Employees Is Worth More Than You Might Think
Anyone who has owned a business for a while knows how disruptive employee turnover can be. There’s the expense of recruiting and training a replacement, of course, but there’s also lost productivity, the time spent getting someone up to speed, and the possibility that customers or other employees become frustrated in the process. For a small business, losing even one or two experienced employees can create a real headache.
A retirement plan isn’t going to solve every employee retention problem, but there’s some interesting research suggesting it can make a meaningful difference.
In July 2026, payroll provider Gusto published a study examining employee retention at small businesses that offer 401(k) plans. Using payroll records from more than 500,000 businesses, researchers found that companies offering a 401(k) experienced approximately 8% fewer first-year employee quits than otherwise similar businesses without one. In some industries, the difference was even greater.
The researchers compared businesses with similar characteristics, including size, industry, compensation, and geographic location. That makes the findings particularly interesting, although it’s important to recognize that the study establishes an association, not necessarily that offering a 401(k) directly caused the improvement.
Still, the economic implications are worth considering. If providing a retirement benefit helps you retain even one employee who might otherwise leave, the savings associated with avoiding a replacement could offset a meaningful portion of the plan’s cost. And that doesn’t account for the less tangible benefits of having a more experienced, stable workforce.
How Can a $15,000 Employee Benefit Cost So Little?
Here’s where things get particularly interesting.
The SECURE 2.0 Act, passed in late 2022, expanded federal tax incentives designed to encourage small businesses to establish retirement plans. Depending on the number of employees and other eligibility requirements, businesses can qualify for two important types of credits:
- Startup cost credits: Eligible businesses with 50 or fewer employees can receive credits covering 100% of qualifying plan startup and administrative expenses, subject to annual limits, for up to three years.
- Employer contribution credits: Qualifying businesses can receive credits for employer contributions made on behalf of eligible employees, up to $1,000 per employee annually. The credit is available for five years, with the percentage gradually declining after the second year.
There’s an important distinction here. A tax deduction reduces the amount of income subject to tax, while a tax credit directly reduces the tax you owe, subject to applicable limitations. A $5,000 tax deduction might save you $1,600 if you’re in the 32% federal income tax bracket. A fully usable $5,000 tax credit, on the other hand, reduces your tax bill by $5,000.
That difference can dramatically change the economics of establishing a retirement plan.
Let’s Look at a Business With 10 Employees
Suppose you own a profitable S corporation with 10 employees who qualify for the contribution credit. You establish a 401(k) plan that provides $1,500 annually toward each employee’s retirement.
That’s $15,000 going directly into your employees’ retirement accounts, which is a meaningful benefit for a small business to provide.
Now let’s look at the potential federal tax benefits during the first year.
Item | Amount |
Total employer retirement contributions | $15,000 |
SECURE 2.0 employer contribution tax credit | −$10,000 |
Remaining deductible contributions | $5,000 |
Federal income tax savings at 32% | −$1,600 |
Estimated after-tax contribution cost | $3,400 |
Think about that for a moment. Your employees receive $15,000 toward their retirement, but your estimated after-tax contribution cost is only $3,400. That’s roughly a 77% reduction in the effective cost of providing those contributions.
Now, there are some assumptions here. All 10 employees must qualify for the credit, the business owner must be able to use the credits, and the remaining deductible contributions must generate the assumed 32% federal income tax benefit. For S corporation owners, the qualified business income deduction can also affect the calculation. We’re also excluding plan administration expenses, which may themselves qualify for additional startup tax credits.
Nevertheless, the broader point is difficult to ignore. A benefit that initially appears to cost $15,000 might have a considerably smaller impact on your bottom line than you expected.
What About Your Own Retirement?
So far, we’ve focused on employees, but there’s another potential benefit that I think deserves just as much attention: the business owner’s own retirement savings.
Many small business owners reinvest most of their profits into the company, particularly during the early years. That’s understandable, but it can create a situation where someone has built a successful business without accumulating much in retirement accounts outside of it.
I’ve seen how this can become a problem as owners approach retirement. Their business may be worth a substantial amount, but that doesn’t necessarily translate into having enough liquid investments to support their retirement. Selling a business can also be a lengthy and unpredictable process, particularly when the owner has spent decades building something that depends heavily on their personal involvement.
A 401(k) can help address that problem while providing additional tax-planning opportunities.
Consider an S corporation owner earning $500,000 annually between W-2 compensation and pass-through business income. If that owner doesn’t have a retirement plan, they may be missing an opportunity to make substantial pretax contributions each year.
For example, an owner under age 50 receiving $150,000 in W-2 wages could potentially contribute $24,500 in employee deferrals and another $37,500 in employer contributions under the 2026 rules, assuming the plan permits those contributions and applicable testing requirements are satisfied.
That’s $62,000 going toward retirement in a single year.
At a 32% marginal federal income tax rate, those pretax contributions could produce approximately $19,840 in current federal income tax savings before accounting for the qualified business income deduction and other tax interactions. The money will generally be taxable when withdrawn in retirement, so we’re talking about tax deferral rather than necessarily eliminating those taxes forever.
One important consideration for S corporation owners is that retirement plan contributions are generally calculated using W-2 compensation, not shareholder distributions. That means the way you compensate yourself can have a significant impact on how much you’re eligible to contribute.
The point isn’t simply to maximize contributions or minimize taxes in any given year. It’s to develop a coordinated strategy that balances the owner’s retirement needs, the cost of providing benefits to employees, and the financial health of the business.
What Happens When the Tax Credits Run Out?
There’s one catch worth discussing. The enhanced tax credits for employer contributions don’t last forever.
Under the current rules, qualifying businesses with 50 or fewer employees can receive contribution credits according to the following schedule:
Plan year | Credit percentage |
Years 1 and 2 | 100% |
Year 3 | 75% |
Year 4 | 50% |
Year 5 | 25% |
Year 6 and beyond | 0% |
These percentages apply to qualifying employer contributions, subject to the $1,000-per-employee annual credit limit and other eligibility requirements.
In other words, the first couple of years can be especially attractive, but the employer contribution credits gradually disappear. By the sixth year, the business is responsible for the full cost of its contributions, although ordinary tax deductions may still be available.
Does that mean establishing a plan is only worthwhile for the first five years? Not necessarily.
The more useful question is whether the retirement plan makes sense as a long-term employee benefit and retirement savings strategy, with the tax credits providing an unusually attractive opportunity to get started.
If the plan helps retain good employees, improves your ability to recruit new ones, and allows you to accumulate more wealth for retirement, those benefits don’t suddenly disappear when the credits expire.
That said, I wouldn’t recommend establishing an expensive retirement plan solely because the government is offering a temporary tax incentive. The plan still needs to make financial sense once those incentives are gone.
How Do You Know Whether Your Business Qualifies?
The credits can be substantial, but they’re not available to every business. Before assuming you qualify, there are several things worth reviewing.
- Number of employees: The most generous credits generally apply to businesses with 50 or fewer employees, although certain credits are available to businesses with as many as 100 employees.
- Employee compensation: For 2026, the employer contribution credit excludes contributions for employees earning more than $110,000 in applicable wages.
- Existing retirement plans: Businesses that have maintained certain retirement plans in recent years may not qualify for the startup credits.
- Ownership structure: Related businesses and certain family relationships can affect eligibility. A business consisting solely of an owner and spouse generally won’t qualify for the startup credits.
- Plan design: The contribution formula, employee eligibility rules, and administrative requirements can materially affect the economics.
It’s also important to understand that these are federal income tax credits, and the amount you can actually use depends on your tax circumstances. The credits generally fall under the general business credit rules, which can limit how much benefit you receive in a particular year.
For those reasons, I would want to see the numbers modeled before making a decision. It’s relatively easy to estimate the headline tax credit, but determining the actual after-tax cost requires looking at the entire picture.
A Retirement Plan Should Be Good for Everyone Involved
As a small business owner myself, I appreciate how difficult it can be to balance profitability with taking care of the people who help make a business successful. You want to compensate employees fairly, provide meaningful benefits, and give them reasons to stay. At the same time, you have to make sure the business remains financially healthy, because none of those benefits matter much if the company can’t afford to sustain them.
What I find particularly appealing about these retirement plan incentives is that they can help address several of those objectives at once. Employees receive an opportunity to build wealth for their own futures, the business may benefit from improved retention, and the owner gains another way to save for retirement while potentially reducing taxes.
Of course, there are tradeoffs. Retirement plans require administration, ongoing contributions can become a meaningful expense, and the tax credits won’t last indefinitely. For some businesses, the numbers simply won’t work, and that’s fine.
But for a profitable small business that doesn’t currently offer a retirement plan, I think this is an opportunity worth examining. The potential tax savings can be substantial, particularly during the first five years, and the longer-term benefits may extend well beyond the tax incentives themselves.
If you’re considering establishing a retirement plan for your business, I’d suggest starting with a straightforward analysis of the potential costs, tax credits, and benefits for both you and your employees. You might be surprised by what the numbers show.
Sources
- Gusto, Small Businesses That Offer a 401(k) Keep More of Their New Hires, July 2026.
- Internal Revenue Service, Retirement Plans Startup Costs Tax Credit.
- Internal Revenue Service, Instructions for Form 8881.
- Internal Revenue Service, Notice 2025-67, 2026 retirement plan limits.
- Internal Revenue Code, Section 45E, Small Employer Pension Plan Startup Costs.
Steven Neeley, CFP®, is the founder of Fortress Capital Advisors, a fee-only fiduciary financial advisory firm based in Carmel, Indiana, serving business owners, executives, and individuals preparing for retirement.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not intended as individualized tax, legal, or investment advice. Consult with qualified professionals regarding your specific circumstances.
Important Disclosure
This article is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered individualized tax, legal, or financial advice. All examples are hypothetical and provided for illustrative purposes only. Actual tax savings and retirement plan costs will vary depending on individual circumstances, including business structure, employee eligibility, income, applicable tax rates, and the ability to utilize available tax credits. Additional factors, such as the qualified business income (QBI) deduction, may affect the tax benefits illustrated. Business owners should consult with their tax advisor and a qualified retirement plan professional before establishing a plan or making decisions based on the examples provided.